Studies have shown that when it comes to decisions, humans inescapably fall prey to the phenomena known as anchoring bias—a cognitive effect recognized by Nobel-prize-winning behavioral psychologists Kahneman and Tversky—in which people make judgments relative to an initial reference value. Anchoring bias and its social influence have been the subject of multiple studies and have the potential to offer tremendous insight for marketers who seek to optimize pricing strategies and build a strong brand.
This article examines the anchoring effect in both marketing and consumer behavior from a comprehensive perspective, spanning from definitions and how it works to strategies for using it and examples of anchor bias in marketing. Furthermore, we examine questions regarding cognitive psychology, customer segmentation, experience marketing, and more, with the aim of providing actionable points for businesses looking to understand and use the power of this cognitive effect.
What is the Anchoring Effect?
The anchoring effect is a cognitive bias that influences an individual’s decision-making or estimating processes. It occurs when an initial value, such as a price of a product or a reasonable estimate of something, establishes a reference point from which subsequent decisions (or estimations) are anchored by the person. This “anchoring” creates a bias for which the individual will assign more importance to the initial values than other potential alternatives. The concept of the anchoring effect was first introduced and discovered by psychologists Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky, who studied the effects of prior information on people’s decision-making.
Anchoring bias has proved to be a major influencing factor in marketing, business, and other disciplines, strong enough to carry over into subsequent decisions, while the anchor may have little to do with the actual situation. The anchor can come from two sources: internal and external. Internally anchored values are based on things like past experiences, emotions, and beliefs, while externally anchored values originate from sources outside of the person, such as information from other groups or the environment.
Definition of the Anchoring Effect
The anchoring effect is a cognitive bias that causes people to rely too heavily on the first piece of information they receive when making decisions, whether it is true or not. First identified by psychologists Daniel Kahnemann and Amos Tversky in 1974, the anchoring effect refers to this initial value that is set or an anchor and how it influences the decision maker’s judgment.
In their experiments, high school students were presented with two equations consisting of eight digits each. The average of the estimates of the two equations given by the students indicated the anchoring effect, as the average answer for 8 x 7 x 6 x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 1 was 2,250, whereas the correct answer, according to them, was 512 when presented with 1 x 2 x 3 x 4 x 5 x 6 x 7 x 8. This illustrates how most people pay more attention to the first value they encounter.
The concept of customer experience has been around since Abbott first mentioned it in 1956, and the anchoring effect in marketing relies on this idea. Companies apply the concept of a first price that is higher than what would normally be expected for a similar range of the same item, with the expectation that customers who see this price perceive the following prices as lower. According to Furnham and Boo, the anchoring effect biases decision-makers toward the dominant anchor/value.
How Does the Anchoring Effect Work?
The concept of the anchoring heuristic is at the core of the anchoring effect research. Epley and Gilovich conducted a study and concluded that when it comes to consumer decisions, several factors influence what people pay attention to and are strongly influenced by the first piece of information they come across. In terms of cognitive biases, the anchoring effect involves different types of anchors: internal and external. Internal anchors rely on the individual’s prior knowledge, associated beliefs, prejudices, and mental frames of reference, while external anchors rely on environmental cues and external references, such as advertisements and promotional strategies. The adjustment heuristic helps explain the reason why different situational scenarios lead to different outcomes. This phenomenon derived from Tversky and Kahneman’s famous “wheel of luck” experiment led to the further development of the anchor effect in the field of psychology.
Apart from psychology, the anchoring effect has been researched and applied in financial management, asset evaluation, legal judgment, and medicine, demonstrating its influence in many domains. Studies found that people who possess a low self-confidence level are more vulnerable to the anchoring effect. Furthermore, random values can also affect consumers’ price perception since agencies are already familiar with all the actual price figures presented to them. Thus, the benefit of these ‘high starting points’ or initial values serves as an anchor.
The anchoring effect manipulates people’s perception and valuation of concepts in numerous ways. People tend to overestimate an anchor when it is relatively high and underestimate it when it’s relatively low. Potential buyers are more likely to accept a higher market price if they have been first presented with a higher anchor. On the contrary, if the anchor is low, people will expect goods and services to be cheaper than they really are.
All in all, the anchoring effect works by relying too much on the first bit of information heard, focusing on own emotions instead of the other party/situation, and basing decisions primarily on the principle of unconscious influence by environmental information. Such cognitive shortcuts are commonplace and establish a potential starting point used to guide our behaviors.
Impact of Anchoring Effect in Marketing on Your Business
The anchoring effect is a phenomenon in which an individual forms an initial reference point, or anchor, for making subsequent decisions and evaluations about products, services, prices, and other entities. Cognitive psychology research has shown that the anchoring effect significantly influences a consumer’s psychological makeup, attitudes, beliefs, knowledge and skills, liquid assets, and self-confidence level when making purchasing decisions.
Companies can leverage the anchoring effect in their marketing strategies to better influence customer decisions and attract more customers.
How to Use the Anchoring Effect to Market Better?
The concept of using the anchoring effect in marketing has gained increasing attention due to its ability to persuade potential customers to purchase a product or service. This phenomenon is based on the notion that past experiences, perceptions, and personal factors serve as anchor points, influencing the decision-making process and affecting individuals’ choices. According to cognitive psychologists, the so-called anchoring bias is when people rely heavily on one item of information, such as the first price they see, when making decisions.
By taking advantage of this effect, companies can present higher initial prices, thus anchoring a prospective customer’s perception in a certain direction. The main objective is to get prospective customers to base their decision solely on the final price rather than the original price. This way, businesses can easily increase sales without having to make the final price very expensive.
To persuade customers effectively using the anchoring effect, marketers should first offer a few options for a product or service, in addition to customer testimonials highlighting the positive outcomes of buying the product. This strategy is believed to reduce the psychological impact of price increases, which is called the ‘anchoring effect in marketing.’ Companies selling items with complex features and specifications can use the anchoring effects to help customers focus on the benefits and features rather than simply on the cost.
An experiment conducted among high school students in 2004 showed how strongly influenced these young people were by an irrelevant anchor. The experimenters used a survey of sixteen questions connected to an irrelevant number, like the weight of a brick, as an anchor. Participants had to answer all sixteen questions within five minutes. It was found that those participants who received a larger anchor gave answers closer to the anchor than those who received a lower anchor. This experiment highlights the significant impact of the anchor on decision-making, even when the anchors are entirely from irrelevant information.
The famous psychology professor Tversky coined the term ‘anchoring heuristic’ to illustrate the human tendency to depend highly upon the initial information we receive when making decisions. People tend to pay more if the starting amount is higher, regardless if it is relevant or not, which shows just how much more value strongly the anchoring effect can influence our purchasing decisions. This phenomenon is caused by cognitive biases, meaning a pattern of deviation from rational decisions due to certain mental processes.
In pricing products, for instance, companies can set an anchor as the starting price of a product or service. Other prices can then be compared directly to this first price so that when customers look at them, they will believe that they have made a rational decision. Interestingly, when it comes to pricing services, research suggests that buyers take the same amount of time to decide whether to accept the services no matter what the final price is—without factoring in individual differences from the original price.
Another example of the power of the anchoring effect is in negotiations. Studies have revealed that establishing a starting point at the onset of a negotiation process has an impact on the final result. This can be seen in numerous studies which measure how this affects the overall outcome. For example, when two groups of people were asked to estimate the weight of an item, the first group was asked to guess the weight of an animal that weighed 200 pounds, while the second group was asked to guess the weight of an animal that weighed 600 pounds. Results showed that the first group estimated the weight of an animal significantly lower than those of the second group. This illustrates how offering an anchor creates anchor bias in subsequent decisions even when the anchor appears irrelevant to the decision maker.
The trick to leveraging the anchoring effect in marketing lies in finding creative ways to capture potential buyers’ attention and guide them toward the company’s solution. Techniques such as positioning the most expensive option first, offering packages of services or products at different levels of pricing, and using persuasive language can be effective ways to use this effect to increase sales. Some businesses also create anchors through product placement, which subtly reminds customers of the amazing features throughout the buying funnel.
The Anchoring Effect on Your Business
The anchoring effect is a psychological phenomenon that has the potential to have a significant influence on customer decision-making. By understanding how this effect works, businesses can use it to their advantage and create effective marketing strategies that minimize costs while maximizing profits.
Anchors are based on past experiences, perceptions, and personal factors, which can have varying impacts on customer behavior. They act as frames of reference during the decision-making process by providing customers with an initial point from which they make further decisions. For example, if a customer sees a product priced at $100 but then finds out it was originally priced at $200, they may be more likely to purchase the item due to its perceived value being a lower price than what it was initially listed for.
However, there are some potentially negative aspects of anchoring in customer decision-making, such as buyers becoming too reliant on anchors or making irrational decisions based solely on them without considering other factors like the quality or features of the product itself. To avoid these issues, companies should be aware of customer tendencies when creating marketing campaigns and provide reliable information about products so buyers can make informed decisions.
Companies should also create an environment that stimulates buyers’ decision-making process by using copy that emphasizes product features and using social proof to establish anchors through niche marketing campaigns or reviews from previous customers who have purchased similar items before. Additionally, businesses should inform buyers about the anchoring effect and how it works, so they understand why certain prices are set for particular products or services offered by companies in order to maximize profits while minimizing costs associated with production and advertising expenses.
In conclusion, understanding the anchoring triangle is essential for businesses looking to increase sales through effective marketing strategies tailored toward consumer needs and preferences while avoiding any potential pitfalls associated with relying too heavily on anchors during buyer decision-making processes.
Examples of Anchoring Bias in Marketing
The anchoring effect is a cognitive bias that has been studied extensively in marketing. It occurs when individuals base their decisions on the initial information they receive and use it to shape their subsequent judgments. Companies can use the anchoring effect to great advantage in the market by influencing the decisions of customers and encouraging them to pay more for their products or services.
This includes strategies such as marketing copy which creates an anchor bias, social proof that establishes price anchors, and niche marketing, which contributes to the development of an anchor bias.
Marketing Copy Creating Anchor Bias
The anchoring effect occurs when people make judgments and decisions based on initial information. Our brains tend to focus on this information, creating a bias toward subsequent decisions. This effect has been studied extensively in marketing, business people, and economics, with researchers Epley and Gilovich finding that those who had more knowledge and experience were less easily influenced by anchor bias.
Due to its significant impact, marketers must be mindful of the prices they create and carefully consider how they affect customer decisions. For example, a company selling a product at the same price point as their competitor may be tempted to reduce the cost to promote their product—but this could have the opposite effect, i.e., increasing prices sometimes results in a sales boom—just a few cents may lead consumers to believe the product is being offered at the top rate, also known as “price transparency.” To take full advantage of this phenomenon, posts and ads should contextualize the items sold within their category, capitalizing on first impressions and establishing their position as the cheaper choice.
Other strategies, such as keeping prices lower than the standard deviation, introducing bundle pricing and discounts, and avoiding printing prices altogether, can help reduce the influence of the anchoring effect and create positive customer relationships. Businesses must understand how the anchoring effect impacts their customers’ decisions and be aware of potential biases when making pricing decisions.
Social Proof Establishing Anchor Bias
The methods discussed above are great ways to use the anchoring effect in marketing. However, social proof is another great way to establish anchor bias, as demonstrated in Kenneth Manning and David Sprott’s findings. Pre-selecting options in forms or including customer testimonials toward the establishments have the potential to shape customer decisions.
Through customer experience marketing, companies can leverage the customer journey to eliminate customer indecision. Experiential marketing, relationship marketing, database marketing, and other network marketing are all great strategies used to engage customer loyalty. These strategies allow businesses to target specific audiences and cultivate relationships through continuous customer feedback, ultimately helping to increase brand trust and customer insights.
Niche Marketing Inspiring Anchor Bias
The anchoring effect can also be leveraged through niche marketing. This type of marketing works to narrow down customer preferences to a subset of markets and industries. By targeting specific demographics, brands are able to emotionally invest customers into one product or service. This deepens customer loyalty, ultimately making them more susceptible to paying higher prices for the same item.
For example, a vehicle specialist dealership may ask customers to agree to a higher price before they look at any cars, caching in on customer loyalty and utilizing the anchoring effect in marketing. Alternatively, a jewelry store may showcase a larger font, a more expensive piece of jewelry first, an anchor to which all other pieces would be compared, leading customers to spend more than what they came willing to pay for.
These examples demonstrate how businesses may employ the anchoring effect to encourage higher spending from their customers. It is important for companies to be conscious of the implications of this strategy and utilize it responsibly. Anchoring using negative methods may damage businesses’ reputations and hurt customer relations.
The Anchoring effect in marketing can be an effective tool for businesses when used strategically and responsibly. When used properly, the anchoring effect fosters customer relationships and encourages customers to spend more.
There are several marketing strategies that rely on the Anchoring effect, such as copywriting, social proof, and niche marketing, to increase sales and build more meaningful relationships with customers. However, it is important to remain mindful of pricing and include attractive offers, as this will enable companies to capitalize on first impressions and create more loyalty with potential customers.
Ultimately, by understanding how the Anchoring Effect works and implementing appropriate marketing strategies, companies will be able to engage more effectively with their customers and ultimately increase the number of loyal customers and overall sales.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is an example of anchoring in advertising?
An example of anchoring in advertising can be seen in ALDI’s ‘Like’ ads, where they initially present higher priced products to influence the viewer’s perspective before revealing their lower cost option.
This is a classic anchoring in marketing technique used to impact consumer perception.
If you want to sell your product, you should learn how psychology marketing can help you upgrade your business strategy.
What is the anchoring effect in advertising?
The anchoring effect in advertising is when an initial price or offer is provided to the consumer, and then other prices are presented after. This causes the consumer to compare the mid-price option, and all other prices offered to the original one, making it a strong influence on their purchase decision.
By anchoring, audiences are biased toward the discount and the advertiser’s product. This cognitive bias positively affects the audience’s response to different pricing options, favoring the product offered by the advertiser.
May 18, 2022, is the date when this effect will be in full force. Consumers will be more likely to purchase the product with the most attractive offer, and the advertiser will benefit from the increased sales.
What is anchoring in digital marketing?
Anchoring in digital marketing is a cognitive bias that influences consumer behavior. It takes advantage of our tendency to base our decisions and opinions on the first piece of information given by presenting a higher initial price or value as a point of comparison.
This results in consumers viewing any other prices or values as more favorable in comparison.
What is an example of anchoring in business?
An example of anchoring in business is when retailers offer deals or discounts. By providing a reference to the original price (anchor), any discounted prices appear much lower than they would otherwise and can entice customers to purchase or sell products that they may not have considered before.
What is an example of anchoring heuristic marketing?
An example of anchoring heuristic marketing can be seen with ALDI’s ‘Like’ ads, which use price comparison to anchor the audience’s view on price before presenting the more cost-efficient ALDI option.
This is a classic example of how companies use heuristics to influence customer decision-making.